After a few times I ask my smoker friends, then I decide.
MUI fatwa Haram Merokok is overshoot, because millions of people might hang their live from the cigarette industry. Ranging from tobacco farmers, cigarette industry workers, the marketing cigarette distributor, sales, etc. In my village, there are a lot of tobacco farmers in Cindaga area such Gilisampir, Wlahar and Poncot. Even there is not cigarette factory in Cindaga village, but it doesn’t mean less impact.
According to our simple minds, it's not a problem for us to stop smoking. Yet while smoking is known as makruh (disliked), it has not been classified as a crime or haram in the past. And if you can stop smoking would be a good of saving money.
If only Indonesian government policies and MUI Fatwa (instructions) were in harmonious. Then it would be the best, because fatwa recently issued by the MUI is too ridiculous. If the government does not take the tobacco tax it won’t make a big contradiction like nowadays.
If MUI forbid children and woman from consuming cigarette, while the Indonesian government still wants to take tobacco tax, it would be look like vehicles who have two drivers. The majority Muslim people of Indonesia become confused and in doubt. This does not mean I do not support the MUI, but because I love the MUI too much. I do not want and really do not like that MUI being harassment object. I do not want MUI Fatwa is not valued. And jobless problem in Indonesia should be considered too. Remember! "kaadal fukro ayyakuuna minal kufron, mean: almost the poverty bring to the crime (unbelief, rebellion)
Would that be great if we learn from the historical era? Such as Demak Sultanate commissioned Sunan Giri as the head of mufti (kind of MUI in that era). Which the mufti is respected by all Muslim in the whole Indonesian archipelago. While they (sultan and mufti) are best match partner.
Honestly, I just want Indonesian Government fully support MUI at 100 %.
Amen.
According to our simple minds, it's not a problem for us to stop smoking. Yet while smoking is known as makruh (disliked), it has not been classified as a crime or haram in the past. And if you can stop smoking would be a good of saving money.
If only Indonesian government policies and MUI Fatwa (instructions) were in harmonious. Then it would be the best, because fatwa recently issued by the MUI is too ridiculous. If the government does not take the tobacco tax it won’t make a big contradiction like nowadays.
If MUI forbid children and woman from consuming cigarette, while the Indonesian government still wants to take tobacco tax, it would be look like vehicles who have two drivers. The majority Muslim people of Indonesia become confused and in doubt. This does not mean I do not support the MUI, but because I love the MUI too much. I do not want and really do not like that MUI being harassment object. I do not want MUI Fatwa is not valued. And jobless problem in Indonesia should be considered too. Remember! "kaadal fukro ayyakuuna minal kufron, mean: almost the poverty bring to the crime (unbelief, rebellion)
Would that be great if we learn from the historical era? Such as Demak Sultanate commissioned Sunan Giri as the head of mufti (kind of MUI in that era). Which the mufti is respected by all Muslim in the whole Indonesian archipelago. While they (sultan and mufti) are best match partner.
Honestly, I just want Indonesian Government fully support MUI at 100 %.
Amen.

i agree with your opinion that this confuses the people when the government decides to campaign against the cigarette yet collects sin taxes. perhaps, the government can impose laws designating areas for smokers who would smoke at their gusto without trampling on other people's right to a clean and fresh air. with this, the government will have the moral ascendancy to collect due taxes. as to the decision of the religion, i would respect that. thanks for visiting my blog...
Mantap cuy...
sukses ya...
silahkan mampir..
http://gitarkeren.blogspot.com
setujuuuuuu
stop merokok y
gak baik juga buat kesehatan
I have to stop (reading), and start (smoking).
:)
kalo haram merokok bagi anak di bawah 17 tahun atau lebih sepesifiknya pelajar g masalah, tapi haram merokok bagi semuanya akan menimbulkan dampak ekonomi di indonesia semakin buruk dikarenakan pabrik rokok akan gulung tikar dan terjadi PHK besar besaran, iya toooooo. kalo saya setuju dengan aa_bas. kaya kuwe lah...
apa gunane petani mbako kon pada nandur mbako nek ora ngrokok ya ora bisa ngerti mbako endi sing berkualitas, pol-pole bangkrut maning akeh garong maning, mergane PHK gede gedean pabrik rokok ora bisa nglinting karo adol rokok, impor biayane larang cuke ne tambah larang. sepisan maning setuju lah karo aa_bas. kaya kue lah....
vicktor hutahuruf@palah.com
buat masyarakat banyumas cilacap besok 9 april bisa centang sunarto no 5 dari PBB (27)utk perubahan
I found this site using [url=http://google.com]google.com[/url] And i want to thank you for your work. You have done really very good site. Great work, great site! Thank you!
Sorry for offtopic
Now flagyl 10mg didronel Side-effects actos 50mg imdur RX tegretol Discount grifulvin v
Smoking kills and it is haram.
you guys should read up on electronic cigarettes. they have no health side effects. inshallah we all quit smoking some day. check out my blog for more information. www.vapordayz.com
74442.....3204